diff --git a/wrenchboard/src/shared_tool/reco_egine.cc b/wrenchboard/src/shared_tool/reco_egine.cc
index 3db05c74..bf5d5c6d 100644
--- a/wrenchboard/src/shared_tool/reco_egine.cc
+++ b/wrenchboard/src/shared_tool/reco_egine.cc
@@ -187,7 +187,7 @@ long RecoCheckFamilyLogin(int itm_count, CVars in, CVars &out  ){
                         snprintf(vname, sizeof (vname), "card_icon_%05d", ic);
                         out[vname] = "icon1";
 
-                        snprintf(vname, sizeof (vname), "banner_%05d", i);
+                        snprintf(vname, sizeof (vname), "banner_%05d", ic);
                         out[vname] ="https://blog.wrenchboard.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/01/wrechboard-sample.jpg";
 
                     ret = PHP_API_OK;
@@ -229,7 +229,7 @@ long RecoCheckFamilyCount( int itm_count, CVars in, CVars &out  ){
                             snprintf(vname, sizeof (vname), "card_icon_%05d", ic);
                             out[vname] = "icon1";
 
-                            snprintf(vname, sizeof (vname), "banner_%05d", i);
+                            snprintf(vname, sizeof (vname), "banner_%05d", ic);
                             out[vname] ="https://blog.wrenchboard.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/01/wrechboard-sample.jpg";
 
                         ret = PHP_API_OK;
@@ -271,7 +271,7 @@ long RecoCheckCoupons( int itm_count, CVars in, CVars &out  ){
                             snprintf(vname, sizeof (vname), "card_icon_%05d", ic);
                             out[vname] = "icon1";
 
-                            snprintf(vname, sizeof (vname), "banner_%05d", i);
+                            snprintf(vname, sizeof (vname), "banner_%05d", ic);
                             out[vname] ="https://blog.wrenchboard.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/01/wrechboard-sample.jpg";
 
                         ret = PHP_API_OK;
@@ -316,7 +316,7 @@ long RecoCheckBlog( int itm_count, CVars in, CVars &out  ){
                                 snprintf(vname, sizeof (vname), "card_icon_%05d", ic);
                                 out[vname] = "icon1";
 
-                                snprintf(vname, sizeof (vname), "banner_%05d", i);
+                                snprintf(vname, sizeof (vname), "banner_%05d", ic);
                                 out[vname] ="https://blog.wrenchboard.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/01/wrechboard-sample.jpg";
 
                             ret = PHP_API_OK;